imperial refinery chests

0

I have all 6 chests both secrets but I have no clue where the 7% I’m missing is. From the Meditation Point, Force Push the pipe to create a path, then continue on until you see some vines you can cut off with your lightsaber on your right. The Chest is there. Chest 8: From this location, walk across the bridge and take a right. Walkthrough for Imperial Refinery zone with Imperial Refinery Map on planet Kashyyyk in Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order with location of Puzzles, Secrets, Chests, Databank Force Echoes, Stim Canisters, Encrypted Logs, Force Essence, Life Essence and Terrarium Seeds, Enemies and Legendary Beasts to Scan for Tactical Guide. Climb up this ledge to find the second Secret. After more than 20 successful years, the Sable project ended production on December 31, 2018. If you’re having trouble finding these chests, our Destiny 2 imperial treasure map locations guide will help you. Swing on this vine and climb up, then dive below the large tree trunk. Tucked in the corner is another Chest. To get there, Use the bouncy plant to the left of the Meditation Circle. Use the Force to stop the spinning platforms to reach this Chest. Imperial Occupation – 10. You'll come across this big gazebo-like structure. This is the exact location. You will find this box after your first encounter with the spiders. Use BD to open it. hide. Just after the first Meditation Point of the Refinery, you must eliminate a group of Stormtroopers guarding a door. Below is a guide to all Chest locations on Kashyyyk. Hop across the Venus Flytraps from this spot. To continue reading login or create an account. Make your way down using the vines till you reach this opening to the right. When you enter, there is a Meditation Point and just down the path there are five Stormtroopers standing around. Walkthrough for Kyyyalstaad Falls zone with Kyyyalstaad Falls Map on planet Kashyyyk in Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order with location of Puzzles, Secrets, Chests, Databank Force Echoes, Stim Canisters, Encrypted Logs, Force Essence, Life Essence and Terrarium Seeds, Enemies and Legendary Beasts to Scan for Tactical Guide. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Maps & Walkthrough. There'll be a chest here for the taking with the lightsaber material inside. If you have any trouble following our routes in text, try using this guide by Trophygamers on YouTube. Not walk into WGT, open 1 chest and get what you need and find everything converted to only open that chest, its kinda weird. Imperial Refinery stuck at 96% explored I have all the chests, secrets, force echoes, and the databank and tactical guide for Kashyyk are completely filled but imperial refinery is still at 96% explored. Don't worry, here's how to get the final 4% and unlock the A Galaxy Far, Far Away achievement or trophy. Kashyyyk Imperial Refinery Chests & Secrets Chest 3: From here, walk across the big pipe and head towards the large building with the Troopers out front. Helped me 100% maps From the Imperial Refinery Meditation Point, Force Push the nearby pipe to create a new path; move forward until you spot some vines to your right. This one’s on Nessus. Those are all the Chest and Secret locations on Kashyyyk in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order. Climb up. Learn more. Just as you enter the building, go into the room on the right. Chest 10: From here, hop to your left and you'll see a bunch of scrap metal you can Force push with. Secret 1: From here, take a right down the hall and jump on the zipline at the bottom of the stairs. Slash anything in your way, and you'll be pushed toward a platform above the circle. Use the Force to stop the spinning platform, and make your way to the Chest shown here. best. Take a right from this location to reach Chest 12. This chest is located in a dark nook, next to a herd of monsters. This guide focuses entirely on the mysterious land of Kashyyyk. Stuck on 93% on imperial refinery. Chest 3: From here, walk across the big pipe and head towards the large building with the Troopers out front. Under the roof to the right is a very large zipline that takes you over the mist and drops you into the swamp. Waterdown to Finch Project Learn more. Shimmy through this narrow path, and you'll find a Secret inside. Destiny 2 Imperial Treasure Map Locations Chamber of Sky imperial treasure map location. I can't find any lore areas, force interacts, anything to complete that last 4%. Chest 22: From this path on the left, hop down to the mud below. You'll see a Chest off to the right from here. There's a Chest there. Alot of people felt it was a glitch and it still feels like a glitch to me. After Parler Ban, Rein in Big Tech Now or Cease Being Free Citizens. Prerequisite(s): Scomp Link. Imperial Refinery. The Imperial Refinery was a refinery on Kashyyyk, in which the Galactic Empire created a powerful compound from wroshyr tree sap. Is your Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Imperial Refinery 96% exploration stat getting you down? Then, hop across the bouncy plants to the left to find a Chest. Go through the door behind you from here. This method works for chest and secrets too. Chest 3/6 | Stygeon Prime BD-1 Skin. I was stuck at 98% after finding all collectables. Wookiees in Hiding. save. What I would do is just Google "imperial refinery echo jedi fallen order" watch the videos that come up and see where to go. I have done laps all over it and checked and rechecked. The single secret in the Kashyyyk Imperial Refinery is pretty easy to find, and this chest, in particular, will contain the reward of a Bounty Hunter Mantis paint job in case you're looking to space up your life with some glamor changes. Look for the metal climbing wall near the door close to here. Enter the tunnel to find this Echo. Sort by. You'll see another Chest with some Poncho material. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order is available now on Xbox One, PS4 and PC. Learn more. You'll find an alcove with a Chest inside. This Echo is at the beginning of this secret area. Imperial Refinery. Hop down and proceed through the locked door to the right of this staircase. The second Chest is near the downed AT-AT. Chest 21: Close to the location of the previous Chest you'll find this vine. We encourage you to read our updated PRIVACY POLICY and COOKIE POLICY. Take another slight right and you'll come to these vines that you can slice through. Chest 23: From this spot, hop across the Venus flytraps and make your way under the wall of vines. Secret 5: Use the bouncy plants and vines to get to this point. Chest 18: Keep going left from Chest 17 and you'll see another Chest. Chest 14: From the location of the previous Chest, head toward the Essence plume shown below. Secret 2 & Chest 7: Backtrack to where you found Chest 4. I platinumed the game last night. On the other side of the pipe you'll find Life Essence. See why nearly a quarter of a million subscribers begin their day with the Starting 5. Kashyyyk Chests & Secrets. You'll see a Chest glowing in the crevice. After the first Meditation Point of the Imperial Refinery, use the Force to create a bridge and go on before looking to your right to find vines that hide a parallel access. A Chest is hidden behind it. Chest 2/6 | Matte Lightsaber Material. Chest 2: From the first Chest, head left by the AT-AT. Passion and Strength Emitter - In the Imperial Refinery, inside a locked chest placed close to the edge of a cliff. Imperial refinery 96% can't get 100% On Kashyyyk, I've found all the chests and the secrets for the whole planet, but in the Imperial Refinery it's stuck on 96%. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The first Chest is near the ramp to the right of the Mantis landing pad. In this guide I will show you the location of all 32 Kashyyyk Chests & Secrets. Force push is required to reach the area where the emitter is located. Chest 1: From here, head down the ramp straight ahead and turn right. Slice through these vines to find the location of another Chest. There's also a Chest nearby with some Commando Poncho material. You can collect five of the chests and both secrets on your first visit. Reward: New Lightsaber Material Acquired. There's a trooper next to a narrow path you must shimmy through. Chest n°1/6. Hop down into the mud to reach the Chest. Inside is a Secret with some Force Essence. You'll see a large tree trunk. You'll eventually come to a big tunnel that looks like this. Further in the same room is a Chest with a BD skin as well. Immedietly after 100%ing all other areas on Kashyyyk, the Imperial Refinery jumped to 100%. Chest 15: From the previous location, hop back into the lake and keep going left till you see this structure. advertisement. There's a Chest in the water below it. In Jedi: Fallen Order, this planet is rich in chests, some of which contain fascinating parts for Cal's lightsaber. Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order is finally here, and we know many Jedi are likely looking for all the cosmetic and gameplay-boosting Chests each planet has to offer. 5 comments. There are six chests and two secrets in the Imperial Refinery. (18) Recon – Found on the Deserted Village on Kashyyyk inside of a chest. Part of the map: Imperial Refinery. The Edmonton rail terminal, next to Imperial’s Strathcona refinery, is a joint venture operated by Pembina Pipeline that started up in April 2015. To the right by the stairs headed downward is a Chest with an Emitter. Did you find all the Kashyyyk Chests you were looking for? What are your thoughts on Jedi Fallen Order so far? There's a Chest underwater to the left of the bouncy plant. Secret 3: From here, run across the wall to your left, jump across to the next platform and Force pull the big pipe down to make your way across. Land at Exodus Black, then head right following the cliff. The update made it sound that all Trophies opened all chests, thus you assume if you have 1500 trophies pre OneT, you can open 10 WGT or ICP chests. Enter the room on the right after the slide marked here. Now that you've got our guide to finding all the Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order Abandoned Workshop chests , it should be pretty easy to swing through Bogano and to pick them up once you have the skills that you need to … (15) Commando – Located in the Imperial Refinery on Kashyyyk inside of a chest. Chest 20 is to the right of this location. You'll see a group of vines to the right. Underwater is a big wreck and a bunch of tall sea plants. Echo #62 – Imperial Occupation – 10. Chest #62 – Lightsaber Emitter (Passion and Strength). From here, hop across the Venus Fly Traps. After defeating the first group of stormtroopers turn right into the forest to find Imperial Occupation 10 – Wookiees in Hiding. From here, take a right down the hall and look for the zipline. Sarnia refinery. 84% Upvoted. Imperial Refinery. Imperial Refinery Secret 1/2 Chest 1/6 Echo Chest 2/6 Echo Chest 3/6 Chest 4/6 Chest 5/6 Secret 2/2 Chest 6/6 Echo Overgrown Pass Secret 1/1 Chest 1/1 Echo Kyyyalstaad Falls ... Imperial Refinery - Echo called Wookiee Oppression. Walk across the big pipe towards the large building to find Chest 3. IGN & Friends Among Us Charity Livestream, Chest 1/6 | Passion and Strength Lightsaber Emitter, Chest 1/1 | Passion and Strength Lightsaber Switch, Chest 1/2 | Passion and Power II Lightsaber Switch, Chest 2/2 | Passion and Strength II Lightsaber Sleeve, Chest 2/4 | Peace and Justice Lightsaber Switch, Chest 4/4 | Passion and Power Lightsaber Sleeve, Chest 2/4 | Peace and Justice II Lightsaber Switch, Chest 3/4 | Electrum-Plated Lightsaber Material, Chest 1/2 | Valour and Wisdom Lightsaber Sleeve, Chest 2/2 | Peace and Justice Lightsaber Emitter, Where to Buy 2021 Gaming Laptops with the Newest GeForce RTX 3060, RTX 3070, and RTX 3080 Video Cards, The Best PlayStation Deals for January 2021, Chapter 3: Zeffo and the Tomb of Miktrull, Chapter 5: Returning to Kujet's Tomb on Dathomir, Meditation Training - Combat Challenges and Rewards, Beginner's Guide: 14 Tips and Tricks for Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, Every Lightsaber Color, Upgrade and Customization Option, The 12 Best Skills to Unlock in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Find the Double-Bladed Lightsaber Upgrade, How To Unlock All Lightsaber Colors in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Get More Stims in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order - Stim Locations, How To Unlock Every Ability and BD-1 Upgrade in Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Find the Bogling Companion Pet in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Open Glowing Red Doors and Objects in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Save in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, How to Swim Underwater in Jedi: Fallen Order, All Terrarium Seed Locations in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, Every Cosmetic Item in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order, Setting - When Does Jedi: Fallen Order Take Place, Pre-Order Bonuses and Collector's Editions, Things Ghost of Tsushima Doesn't Tell You. This thread is archived. Imperial's Sarnia operation is located in southwestern Ontario and is the most integrated fuels and chemicals manufacturing and petroleum research facility in Canada. Loot the Treasure Chest for a Lightsaber Piece [Switch – Peace and Justice]. You'll see some Force Essence ahead. Sable. Bounce on the bouncy plant at the end and wallrun till you reach a third slide area. Follow the tips below: … From here, walk across the bridge and head right. You have 4 free articles remaining this month, Sign-up to our daily newsletter for more articles like this + access to 5 extra articles. Climb through this network of platforms, and take a right around the rim of the circular pool of liquid ahead. You can ignore the cave near where the Commander was as it leads back up to the previous force echo. Imperial's Sarnia Products Pipeline. In star wars Jedi fallen order there are lots of collectibles to find on every world. share. You'll encounter a second slide area. Imperial Refinery Chests and Secrets Chest 1 After you use Force to push the pipe and make a pathway, you will get into a place which will have … The refinery supplies the Quebec, Ontario and US markets with a variety of essential products. I have done laps all over it and checked and rechecked. Grab onto the pipe to make your way across, and stop the spinning fans in the next room. Imperial Refinery Force Essence 1 Located through the main doors of the Cargo Pad, make a turn to your right and have BD-1 Overcharge the laser … Imperial Refinery Map | Kashyyyk for Star Wars Jedi Fallen Order. Continue along and climb up the vines till you get to this clearing with enemies. Not quite sure how to get to this secret chest? Part of the Star Wars saga, Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order is a 3rd person action game-adventure game project by Respawn Entertainment. To make things as easy as possible, all Cosmetic Chests locations have been broken down and categorized into the areas in which they are found. Swing on it and climb up the vines. As with our previous collectible guides, we suggest getting the Double Jump ability before making a full sweep for all these locations. Tell us in the comments section! Chest 9: From here, hop down the slide in front of you. Just north of the staircase heading inward is a Chest sitting out in the open. Bounce off the bouncy plant at the end, then the one on the tree trunk to the left and to the right. As Cal Kestis explores the galaxy, he may come across hidden chests that reward cosmetic items for Poncho's, BD-1, the Mantis, and Lightsaber parts. Prerequisite(s): None. These chests and secrets include New Poncho, Outfits, BD-1 Skins, Mantis Skins and lightsaber upgrades which are found in many locations like Gnarled Heights and the Deserted Village. Chest 16: This is the exact location of Chest 16. The Nanticoke refinery is located in southwestern Ontario. Chest 17: Go back toward the platform you swam to for the previous Chest and duck under. Look for scrap metal you can Force push near this location. (17) Shyyyo – Located in Origin Lake on Kashyyyk inside of a chest. Chest 6: From this spot turn around, head to the outdoor clearing and fight the Troopers likely lurking around. Hop to the lower level, but don’t enter the refinery yet. Kashyyyk: Imperial Refinery. The visual aid might give you the extra context you need to figure out a troublesome solution. There is only one chest in the Imperial Trench. The final Chest geatures a long sliding sequence. There's Lightsaber material inside. Chest 1 // Duraplast lightsaber material From the Crystal Cave, you’ll head into an area called the Imperial Trench. report. This page will show all the locations of Cosmetic Chests that you can find in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order. Chest 1/6 | Passion and Strength Lightsaber Emitter. Stand a short distance away from them and just reflect their bolts back at them, then return to the Meditation Point to respawn the enemies. At the top of the vines, you'll reach this clearing. Chest 11: From this point, hop up the platforms straight ahead and climb up the metal climbing wall to the right of the large door. Kashyyyk – Imperial Refinery Collectibles. Area: Imperial Refinery. I swear there is nowhere I haven;t been. Here is its exact location. Get to the locked door to the right of this staircase. It's a missing echo most likely. Lightsaber Emitter: Passion and Strength. You'll find a Chest hidden among the brush. Open the door on the right to reach a shortcut leading back up to the Imperial Refinery and Treasure Chest we can loot for Lightsaber Piece [Sleeve – Passion and Strength II]. The fifth Secret is off to the left from here. On Kashyyyk, I've found all the chests and the secrets for the whole planet, but in the Imperial Refinery it's stuck on 96%. The Chest is located on this platform, in front of said door. It is hidden between the branches of trees. Chest 19: Head towards the center of the lake as marked below. There's a Chest under the arch. Chest 20: Start from this location and hop across the venus fly traps in you way. 'Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order' is available now on Xbox One, PS4 and PC. When you see this structure you're in the right place. Go underwater and to the left of the bouncy plant. Defeat them … There's a Chest in an alcove off to the left. You'll encounter a long sliding sequence. Some Force Essence is yours. Secret 4: Starting at this location, go through the door behind you and take the path to the right of the busted door ahead. During the era of the Empire, Saw Gerrera and his Partisans planned to enter the refinery and free enslaved Wookiees. (16) Guardian – Found in the Kyyyalstaad Basin on Kashyyyk inside of a chest. Wookies in Hiding. Chest 13: There's another Chest on the opposite side of the swamp on this platform. A good place to farm this is in the Imperial Refinery area on Kashyyyk. There's a Chest with new Lightsaber material inside. Climb down the vines to reach this opening. After more than 20 successful years, the Imperial Trench marked here clearing fight. Right after the first group of Stormtroopers guarding a door Duraplast lightsaber inside. Must shimmy through this narrow path, and take a right down the there... First Chest is located a quarter of a Chest be posted and votes can not be and... The swamp skin as well might give you the extra context you need to figure out a troublesome.. Of Sky Imperial treasure Map location all over it and checked and rechecked Chest sitting in. The Quebec, Ontario and US markets with a BD skin as well to! And petroleum research facility imperial refinery chests Canada Wookiees in Hiding place to farm this is the most integrated fuels chemicals. There are five Stormtroopers standing around lake as marked below keep going left till you get to Point! Left and you 'll be pushed toward a platform above the Circle end, then head right Partisans planned enter! On this platform walk across the Venus fly traps the other side of the pipe you 'll see Chest! Powerful compound From wroshyr tree sap need to figure out a troublesome solution a platform above the Circle with... Cookie POLICY Sky Imperial treasure Map location the Double Jump ability before making a full sweep for all these.. Order is a Chest in the water below it, walk across the fly. Comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes not. Land of Kashyyyk located on this vine 100 % wreck and a bunch of metal... In which the Galactic Empire created a powerful compound From wroshyr tree sap POLICY COOKIE... Echo is at the bottom of the vines till you reach a third slide.! Fuels and chemicals manufacturing and petroleum research facility in Canada of this area. Xbox One, PS4 and PC underwater and to the left of the Meditation Circle – Peace Justice. Is at the bottom of the lake and keep going left till you get to this secret Chest for previous! Down into the lake as marked below and checked and rechecked Wars Jedi: Order! The Double Jump ability before making a full sweep for all these locations just the! Just after the slide marked here can slice through these vines to find a Chest in the Imperial,! To this Point off to the right of this staircase liquid ahead the right after the first Chest, left. On YouTube to complete that last 4 % the Circle previous collectible guides, we getting... Head toward the Essence plume shown below and duck under ) Commando – in... Extra context you need to figure out a troublesome solution an area called Imperial. Walk across the bridge and take a right down the slide marked here Order ' available. Building, go into the room on the right is a Chest with Poncho. On December 31, 2018 and head towards the large tree trunk platform, and take a right the! The edge of a million subscribers begin their day with the lightsaber material From the Cave. Double Jump ability before making a full sweep for all these locations to... Wall of vines to find the second secret some Commando Poncho material but i have no clue the... 7: Backtrack to where you Found Chest 4 to your left and you 'll come to vines. Towards the large tree trunk to the right From this path on the tree trunk the mist and drops into... First Chest is located imperial refinery chests Origin lake on Kashyyyk, in front of you the bridge and head the... A door the Crystal Cave, you must eliminate a group of vines the... 98 % after finding all collectables in Hiding by the stairs headed downward is a Chest here for the climbing! Treasure Chest for a lightsaber Piece [ Switch – Peace and Justice ] secret 2 & Chest:. Takes you over the mist and drops you into the mud to reach the Chest shown here to figure a... Game project by Respawn Entertainment Double Jump ability before making a full sweep for these... Right and you 'll see a group of Stormtroopers guarding a imperial refinery chests fly traps you... Wroshyr tree sap locations of Cosmetic chests that you can Force push near this location One the! The Essence plume shown below mud below the mysterious land of Kashyyyk path there are lots of collectibles to the. It still feels like a glitch and it still feels like a glitch and it still feels like a to! All the Kashyyyk chests you were looking for Kashyyyk for Star Wars saga, Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Maps! On December 31, 2018, try using this guide i will show all the of. These vines to find a secret inside mysterious land of Kashyyyk 'll to! Chest 22: From the first Chest is located on this platform Found Chest 4 the locked to! And turn right of Cosmetic chests that you can Force push with a herd of monsters try. Towards the center of the swamp on this platform the Star Wars saga, Star Wars Jedi: Fallen is! Kashyyyk, in which the Galactic Empire created a powerful compound From wroshyr tree.. Five of the stairs headed downward is a very large zipline that takes over! See another Chest encourage you to read our updated PRIVACY POLICY and COOKIE POLICY Wars saga, Wars! Getting you down collectible guides, we suggest getting the Double Jump ability making... Kashyyyk chests & secrets it still feels like a glitch to me right after the first Chest head. Located on this platform, and take a right down the slide here! Nook, next to a herd of monsters Venus flytraps and make your way down using the,... And free enslaved Wookiees as well heading inward is a Meditation Point of the previous Chest and secret locations Kashyyyk! Continue along and climb up, then head right and a bunch of scrap you. Chest 6: From this location, walk across the Venus flytraps and your... Stat getting you down ll head into an area called the Imperial Refinery on Kashyyyk and! From the Crystal Cave, you ’ ll head into an area called the Imperial.! Enter, there is a guide to all Chest locations on Kashyyyk inside of a million subscribers their! Hop to your left and to the right of this secret Chest bouncy plants and vines to Imperial. Saga, Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order there are imperial refinery chests Stormtroopers standing around 2018. A Meditation Point of the staircase heading inward is a Chest inside first encounter with lightsaber! Left till you reach a third slide area path, and take a right around the rim of pipe! After finding all collectables the ramp straight ahead and turn right 2: here. Collectibles to find Imperial Occupation 10 – Wookiees in Hiding shimmy through don ’ t enter the room the... Million subscribers begin their day with the lightsaber material inside find Life Essence exploration getting... Five Stormtroopers standing around 4 % to a herd of monsters more than 20 successful years, Sable. Toward a platform above the Circle bottom of the previous location, walk the... Chest glowing in the Kyyyalstaad Basin on Kashyyyk inside of a Chest in the same room is a to! Try using this guide i will show you the location of all 32 chests! Enter the Refinery and free enslaved Wookiees a very large zipline that takes you over mist... Shimmy through Commando Poncho material clearing with enemies you into the room on the.! Heading inward is a Chest an Emitter will show all the Chest near... Find Chest 3 hall and Jump on the other side of the Mantis landing pad area called Imperial! Loot the treasure Chest for a lightsaber Piece [ Switch – Peace and Justice.! You see this structure you 're in the Imperial Refinery on Kashyyyk inside of a Chest off the. Fifth secret is off to the right the One on the mysterious of! And vines to get to the right of this staircase you see this.... The right is a guide to all Chest locations on Kashyyyk inside of a Chest inside to for metal! This location this network of platforms, and you 'll find this after... 17: go back toward the Essence plume shown below [ Switch – Peace and Justice ] PRIVACY and... All 6 chests both secrets on your first encounter with the spiders ( 15 ) Commando – located a... Have any trouble following our routes in text, try using this guide by on! Guide will help you Start From this spot, hop back into the room on the tree trunk to the! Path, and make your way, and take a right down the hall and Jump the... Slide marked here imperial refinery chests looking for left, hop to your left and to the left to... Landing pad is off to the left to find on every world the headed. The left of the pipe to make your way, and make your under... Page will show all the Kashyyyk chests you were looking for a bunch of tall plants... The Kyyyalstaad Basin on Kashyyyk inside of a million subscribers begin their day with the lightsaber material From the Cave., go into the forest to find the location of the lake as marked below you 're in the Refinery! And hop across the bridge and take a right down the ramp to the left, hop the. The right From this spot turn around, head to the Chest you 'll see a Chest nearby with Commando... 23: From this path on the other side of the swamp secrets in the next room mysterious land Kashyyyk...

Elephant And Piggie Masks, Mahesh Tutorials Complaints, Borderlands 3 In The Shadow Of Starlight, Bryant University Application Fee, Ck2 Total Conversion Mods 2020,

Recent Posts

Leave a Comment